Choices, choices. When it comes to men’s footwear there’s no shortage of brands and options. It can seem like a good thing, but some times you can feel overwhelmed and can’t make a decision.
Today we’re going to help you out so you can finally decide on a new pair. The competitors facing off? Allen Edmonds and Alden.
They are two very popular and high quality shoe makers, so we don’t blame you for being on the fence. We will be looking at a few different factors, including material, comfort, pricing and more.
Allen Edmonds vs Alden
Allen Edmonds Review
Based out of Port Washington, Wisconsin, Allen Edmonds was established in Belgium during 1922. Unfortunately it wasn’t the cool Belgium in Europe, but rather Belgium, Wisconsin(Kidding of course).
They have 50 retail stores in 28 states, while also operating in Italy and the Dominican Republic. A lot of their original success came form supplying troops with shoes during World War II, so if you respect the military you’ll appreciate that.
Allen Edmond customers are known for their loyalty. Normally the shoes aren’t replaced but rather restored, making them last for many years to come. The company even offers to rebuild shoes including replacing the sole, heels, reapplying finish, and more.
Are Allen Edmonds high quality?
Allen Edmonds shoes use high quality leathers that are breathable, repel moisture, age beautifully and hold their shape well. The design team is constantly searching for premium hides across the globe to improve the quality of their dress shoes.
Every shoe is required to pass a thorough quality control inspection. This ensures that you only get the best possible pair. A neat thing about Allen Edmonds is they also offer their factory second models, which were shoes that experienced minor defects like scuffs.
Factory seconds some times are indistinguishable from perfect pairs, making them an excellent choice if you’re new to the brand.
Most of their footwear also includes the 360° Goodyear welt. This is a very strong strip of leather that joins the upper and sole that increases durability by tenfold. Your shoes could last so long you’d be passing them onto your children when they grow older.
Are Allen Edmonds comfortable?
Dress shoes need to feel good. How else are you going to sport them to work or when you’re out and about? I don’t know about you, but I hate blisters and scratches from shoes.
You don’t have to worry about that with Allen Edmonds, however. Between the insole and outsole, they place a layer of shock absorbing cork. Your feet form an imprint on the cork, which means every step is comfortable and soft. It shapes to your feet along with the leather to make a full experience.
Are Allen Edmonds expensive?
You’ll probably be spending at least $200 for a lower end model which is still high quality, long lasting and stylish.
They have many shoes that exceed the $400, $500 and $600 range for the gentlemen serious about investing into their footwear.
Once again, you can find their factory seconds for about 50% off if you don’t mind some light blemishes. If you’re good with your hands, you might be able to fix them to restore the pair back to perfection.
Best Allen Edmond Shoes
Allen Edmonds Men’s Strand Cap-Toe Oxford
Do you know whose favorite shoe this is? The president of Allen Edmonds, Paul Graangard. And for good reason. He introduced the Strand when he became head of the company in 2008 as a part of the Timeless Classics Collection.
These balmorals feature a medallion toe, perforations, and are built on the 5-last. They are elegant and feel like walking on pillows every time you take a step.
Allen Edmonds Men’s McAllister Cap-Toe Oxford
The McAllister was originally introduced in 1956 and then brought back in 2009 because of the demand. It features soft calfskin upper and premium leather lining. This makes your pair last longer, look better, and feel comfortable.
A single oak sole and 360 welt construction makes the McAllister durable and sturdy. It will hold up for many years with good care.
Allen Edmonds Men’s Fifth Avenue Walnut Calf Oxford Shoe
Professional and sleek. The Fifth Avenue oxford has a tan calfskin upper that exudes success and confidence. Do you work a corporate job or run a business? Then this shoe is for you.
The Alden Shoe Company has been around for almost a century and a half, founded during 1884 by Charles H in Middleborough, Massachusetts.
During the 19th century, shoemakers in New England were abundant but Alden stood the test of time and is one of the few that remains. They specialize in handmade men’s shoes including oxfords, boots, loafers and more.
A fun fact about Alden is that their model 405 boots were Indiana Jones shoe of choice in the films.
Alden shoes quality
Alden use cordovan leather shells that involve a century old method of vegetable tanning and hand finishing. The process takes up to six months to complete, but the result is a beautiful, soft leather.
They also have calfskin leather shoes, which is another type of leather renowned for its looks and lifespan. Just like Allen Edmonds, Alden also boats Goodyear welted construction, making their shoes extremely resilient. Further more, they offer a restoration service to get your shoes back in tip top shape.
Are Alden shoes durable?
Expect a pair of Alden shoes to last 10 to 20 years with proper care.
High quality leather that ages well, along with good stitching and soles gives their shoes amazing longevity.
Make sure you that keep a good shoe care routine, including cleaning and polishing.
Are Alden shoes comfortable?
Alden shoes feature a cushioned footbed, so your feet feel like their walking on clouds. If you need fashionable shoes that feel great to work in all day, Alden should be a runner up. Cork soles create a durable and insulated environment for your feet, as well.
Are Alden shoes expensive?
Handmade shoes of this caliber won’t come cheap, so you’ll be looking at spending around $500 for a brand new pair of Alden’s. Seeing as this will save you money in the long term, look at it as an investment.
The bottom line
When it comes to Allen Edmonds vs Alden, they have three things in common which are comfort, looks, and quality.
The one thing that separates them is the pricing, since you can get Allen Edmond’s in the $200-300 range but you’ll dropping around double of that for Alden’s.
Who do you think offers better shoes between the two brands?